Preen, Roundup, Surflan and Treflan
Concerning Preen hurting hostas.
Sally Murphy wrote me and said she and Bob had been using Preen for 10
years and it has worked fine. I believe Preen has the same active
ingredient as the agricultural herbicide Treflan.
My herbicide program:
I have been using the pre emergent herbicide Surflan for the first time
this year. It comes with a Turf and Ornamental label and has hostas
listed right on the label. The application rate for hostas in 1.5 to 3
ounces per 1000 square feet. It has directions for mixing Surflan and
Roundup on the label and this is the mix I am going to use all summer.
It is also labeled for container growing use. This Roundup/Surflan mix
is only applied to weeds of course.
This is a weed killing program with two methods of operation. The
Roundup kills the living weeds. (it has been reported that Roundup may
aid in the breaking of dormancy of weed seeds) The Surflan kills weed
seeds in the soil when they germinate where the mix was sprayed to kill
the live weeds.
The Surflan in the mix gives anything sprayed an orange tint letting you
know where you have sprayed.
I know herbicides are a hot topic around here. I hope this starts a
From: Gregory +ACY- Carla Miller +ADw-homemade+AEA-MEGSINET.NET+AD4-
Date: Saturday, April 24, 1999 12:53 AM
Subject: Re: Preen
+AD4-NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
+AD4-It is not safe to use. I called the manufacturer concerning this two
+AD4-ago. They said that if the plant is not listed on the label, do not
+AD4-I explicitly asked about hostas. The gentleman said that it would
+AD4-harm or kill the hosta.
+AD4-See ya Josh+ACE-
+AD4APg- -----Original Message-----
+AD4APg- From: AHS-sponsored members' discussion of genus Hosta +ACY-
+AD4APg- +AFs-mailto:AHSE-MAILROBIN+AEA-HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM+AF0-On Behalf Of Josh Spece
+AD4APg- Sent: Thursday, April 22, 1999 12:42 PM
+AD4APg- To: AHSE-MAILROBIN+AEA-HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM
+AD4APg- Subject: Preen
+AD4APg- Hi everyone,
+AD4APg- Just a quick question...is the pre-emergence herbicide Preen safe to
+AD4APg- on potted hostas? Thanks+ACEAIQ-
+AD4APg- soggy zone 4
+AD4APg- Josh's Garden Web
+AD4APg- In The Country Garden +ACY- Gifts
+AD4APg- JS Web Page Design
+AD4APg- +ACI-There are always two choices.
+AD4APg- Two paths to take. One is easy.
+AD4APg- And its only reward is that
+AD4APg- it's easy.+ACI-
To sign-off this list, send email to email@example.com with the
message text UNSUBSCRIBE HOSTA-OPEN