hort.net Seasonal photo, (c) 2006 Christopher P. Lindsey, All Rights Reserved: do not copy
articles | gallery of plants | blog | tech blog | plant profiles | patents | mailing lists | top stories | links | shorturl service | tom clothier's archive0
Gallery of Plants
Tech Blog
Plant Profiles
Mailing Lists
    Search ALL lists
    Search help
    Subscription info
Top Stories
sHORTurl service
Tom Clothier's Archive
 Top Stories
Disease could hit Britain's trees hard

Ten of the best snowdrop cultivars

Plant protein database helps identify plant gene functions

Dendroclimatologists record history through trees

Potato beetle could be thwarted through gene manipulation

Hawaii expands coffee farm quarantine

Study explains flower petal loss

Unauthorized use of a plant doesn't invalidate it's patent

RSS story archive

Re: Plagiarism Story VIII

  • To: hosta-open@mallorn.com
  • Subject: Re: Plagiarism Story VIII
  • From: Jim Hawes <hawesj@gcnet.net>
  • Date: Sat, 13 Feb 1999 10:47:37 -0500
  • References: <870316@WG1.gcnet.net> <36C507C5.733@gcnet.net>

Jim Hawes wrote:
> Robins,
> The story continues to describe the period up to, including and after
> the Winter Scientific  Meeting in Chicago in late January 1998. Sometime
> in June, 1997 Walek had decreed that Ben's Cultivar Group article was
> not plagiarism because it conformed to the ICNCP Code. Nothing was ever
> said about did he copy, did he use it without permission or without
> citing sources of his  information. Public communication within and
> outside the Robin seemed to slack off considerably. I assumed that a lot
> of people on the Robin felt like I did...dazed, depressed, in a state of
> disbelief, somewhat angry and sad. It was like being sick to the soul
> but I knew I would get out of this state eventually.
> I received lots of private posts from several friends who communicated
> about many of the new examples of copying ideas, word, jokes,
> anecdotes, etc...from the H.tortifrons vein pair example, to the "What
> about Royal Flush?" example mimicking Roberta Diehl's original comment
> concerning Glen's story about his neighbor who planted Hostas in his two
> commodes outside his house under renovation, and many minor "me too"
> types of petty copycatting. Within the rather large group of Robins,
> Ben's reputation as a plagiarist was common knowledge and was ridiculed.
> But no one dared do anything or say anything in public. It was like a
> secret cover up...a taboo subject in public.
> During this period of about eight months from June 1997 to January 1998,
> I was very occupied with my garden and with heart problems. I spent a
> lot of time in reading, studying and documenting more information and
> writing on hosta sports. Tom Micheletti asked me to present a short talk
> on hosta sports at the Midwest Hosta Society Scientific Meeting in
> Chicago in late January 1998. He suggested updating as many Hosta Wheels
> as I had prepared in the Artist's Palette article and present them to
> Meeting attendees. I agreed to do this. I worked throughout the late
> summer on this and had prepared 56 Groups of Related Sports (Wheels, as
> they became known) by the time of the Meeting. I sent them to Tom to
> duplicate about 200 copies.
> The Meeting went well. The Wheels presentation went fine with the new
> information on sports well received. Ben was there. He got a copy of the
> Handout containg 56 Hosta Wheels with much new information added.
> Frankly, I was sorry but I couldn't very well say he couldn't have a
> copy because he was a plagiarist, could I? Besides it was Tom who was
> handing them out.
> In February there appeared to be a flurry of posts from Holland on the
> subject of sports. From the substance of the messages I could tell Ben
> was busy adding to his "BOOK" which he had told us about on several
> occasions. He told us we could buy it at the Peoria Convention. I
> suspected he was copying like crazy all of the new sports I had included
> in the Handout.
> Although I had not communicated with Ben since early June 1997 at the
> time of the Plagiarism Flap, his post to me (see below) appeared that we
> had been in constant and continuing correspondence. On February 13, 1998
> he wrote:
> > Jim
> > thanks for the additional corrections I have tried to incorporate
> > them in my own system , where i have now nearly 800 parents and there
> > sports. This system does not uses wheels or
> > criss-crass arrows. Instead I add in short the color for each plant
> > behind the name ( eg Frances Williams ye) That way they can also be
> >  presented on the computer .
> > I find it a pity that so much effort goes in making these wheels
> > whereas they are for me difficult if not impossible to use despite the
> > fact that for the third time the wheel has "improved" I  still find it impossible to "read
> > from your handout or published wheels the color of the cultivar.  In
> > nearly each case I have to add a question mark. I would appreciate if you
> > could one way or another provide the colors of the new additions ,
> > without referring to the wheel.
> > Ben J.M.Zonneveld
> > Clusius lab pobox 9505
> > 2300 RA Leiden
> > The Netherlands
> > Zonneveld@RULbim.LeidenUniv.NL
> .............................................
> I was flabbergasted. He was at it again. He was copying as I suspected.
> He wanted me to send him more information because he could not figure
> out that the position of the hosta sport on the wheel determined the
> color and pattern of distribution. Even my 10 year old grand daughter
> understood the concept used in the Artist's Palette and Ben PhD
> couldn't???. He was admitting that he was using data  from the Wheels I
> had developed .
> Of course, I refused. I did not answer. I did not give him permission of
> any kind to use the information. Ben was not deterred. Four days later
> he wrote to his Hosta Fans:
> Dear Hopsta Fans
> I would appreciate if you cpould add colors to the following cultivars
> maybe by using the following system
> w=white  y=yellow  cr=cream bl=blue  gr=green  ch=chartreuse
> e=edge  c=center  color not mentioned = green
> Abby dew
> Alligator shoes
> Amy Elizabeth
> Aspen White
> Born Again
> Carols August Halo
> Cassanova
> Chippawa
> Color Parade
> Dress White
> Emerald Carpet
> Gosan Moonskirt
> Irish Breeze
> Irish Spring
> Jupiter
> Lazy River
> Litle River
> Jaded Geisha
> Jupiter
> Lazy River
> Little River
> Merlin
> Millies Memoirs
> Ming Treasue
> Tranquility
> Regalia
> Renaissance
> Rough River
> Sublety
> Mr Spork  (corrected Mr Spock)
> Summer Solstice
> Obsession
> Pomp and Circumstance
> Redolent Nosegay
> Thanks for any help
> Ben J.M. Zonneveld, etc.
> ...................................................
> Flabbergasted again!.. He had the audacity to ask the whole Robin to
> help him figure out the colors of sports I had added to the 56 Wheels
> presented at the Winter Meeting. This list includes many  of my own
> hosta sports, named but not yet registered, other sports of friends who
> told me about their sports. They were added to wheels with their
> permission and names( in parentheses) indicating sources of the plants
> by introducer in most cases. They were placed in their correct position
> on my Handout and Ben still couldn't figure out the colors. And he wants
> to use them in his Book!!!Without approval!!!without citation too
> perhaps. At this time all I knew about the Book was what Ben told us on
> the Robin. But I could tell from his asking for information about my
> list of sports that he intended to use them if he could just figure them
> out. He had not commited plagiarism again...YET...just giving hints that
> he planned to do so.
> Ben completed his book in April so he told us. He sold it at the
> Convention in Peoria for 6 dollars, so I was told. Summer passed. I went
> to Florida in September and did more  studying and writing. Among the
> things I studied was Ben's book. A copy had been given to me by a
> friend. I opened it and there it was.....more plagiarism. Lots and lots
> of my hostas in Ben's Book, hostas known only to me, previously
> published by me having been presented in my Wheels Handout at the Winter
> Meeting. In the frontispiece was the familar boilerplate......Copywrite
> 1998, Duplication of this material prohibited by Ben J.M Zonnerveld,
> etc.   My first thought was .....He steals, then copywrites to prevent
> anyone else from stealing what he has stolen....Outrageous!!!
> Jim Hawes

To sign-off this list, send email to majordomo@mallorn.com with the

 © 1995-2015 Mallorn Computing, Inc.All Rights Reserved.
Our Privacy Statement
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index