Re: [hostapix] Re: Tiaras Again
- Subject: Re: [hostapix] Re: Tiaras Again
- From: LemkeIowa@aol.com
- Date: Fri, 15 Mar 2002 11:18:37 EST
In a message dated 3/13/02 6:23:18 PM, firstname.lastname@example.org writes:
<< >Please direct me to the area were I might find the evidence
> that it is a sport of Gold Edger or Gold Drop
This evidence can best be found at nurseries which sell 'Royal
Tiara' :-) Seriously, why not pick one up and see for yourself. It's a
pretty neat plant to boot. Data doesn't always tell the whole story. This
isn't the only piece of "hosta lore" that everyone accepted at face value,
even though it wasn't true. Remember Hank Zumach's getting 'Sea Sprite'
tested? That was THE plant that raised the first concerns about virus in
hosta, and everyone was convinced that those were the symptoms of a new
virus called Hosta Virus X. In it's first test after years of being the
poster hosta for viruses, it was shown to not have Hosta Virus X or any othe
known virus. Data is only as good as the effort people make to be sure it's
right before turning it into data, but for those who handle large amounts of
information, like George Schmid and Mark Zilis in their books, and you
yourself with your database, it's impossible to check and see if everything
you've been told was correct, or investigate every fact yourself.
Since publishing his book, Mark Zilis has tissue-cultured the
previously hard-to-find 'Royal Tiara' and, having them around to study, is
said to be leaning towards agreeing that it is not a Tiara after all.
Thanks to you, Jim Schwarz and Mark Zilis we have the saga of 'Royal Tiara'
cleared up for the time being. I hate to be a 'Doubting Thomas' all the time
but maybe that goes with the job of collecting data. Sometimes I refer to it
a being a the job of Garbage collecting. As a Hostaholic I always cut of all
hosta scapes as soon as they appear. Anyway that is my excuse for not
catching the clue left on page 201 when he stated the flower was lavender. I
wonder how many of our or your readers looked on page 200 where it says
the'Golden Tiara' flowers are from pale to medium purple.
In the reference section of my PDf file on 'Royal Tiara,' I have added these
two lines>>>>E-mail letters from Bill Meyer and Schwarz-Zilis indicate that
this plant is a 'Tiara' in name only and is probably a sport of 'Gold Edger.'
I don't know if this will help you very much on your trip to fame and
The hardheaded hostaholic,
To sign-off this list, send email to email@example.com with the
message text UNSUBSCRIBE HOSTA-OPEN