Re: Removal Request - Wowzer...
Floyd M. Rogers, Editor (Northern Illinois Hosta Society)-- wrote:
RE:>> Your post...
You have got to be kidding me. I've tried for weeks and weeks
to get people to discuss ploidy conversions, have asked questions about
wintering over plants, have visited with Beth and several others on the
list about seedling propagation, sources for supplies, application of restricted
use chemicals, pests and the treatment regimens for same, and many of other
HOSTA related questions. Sure, she is a political animal, but statements
like yours remind me of a schoolyard bully. She and about 10 others
are the only ones that have been actually taking the time to post anything!!!
Isn't it interesting that many of the same ones that are talking politics
are also the same ones who will take the time to answer your, and everyone
I can see telling her to "put a lid on it", and I can see others telling
ME to "stuff a sock in it, mister", but suggesting that she (and I, next?)
should be removed from the list? Wowzer... That's pretty radical.
Just ask some Hosta questions, Floyd, and tell others to do the same.
And tell those without guts enough to send her a private email to just
quit "whining" to you. In your official capacity, I would think that
you could petition the board for one of those T-Shirts with the big red
circle and the line through it that says, "No Whining". This is the
kind of stiffling censorship that has occurred on the Pheonix and I for
one don't want to support ANY list in deference to another (through publicly
funded auctions) if there is censorship. If you had mailed this privately,
I personally would have felt a lot better about it since discretion is
the better part of valor, but it's too late now. And for those who
can't stomach the adult conversation, well I won't say it...
Sorry that her posts are not well received by all, but this post of
yours is way off the charts, IMHO. Using the title is like trying
to win through intimidation--a top selling book once upon a time, but I
prefer another that is even a bigger seller... I suppose I'd better not
say which book, for fear of cencorship on that issue, too.
Choosing a public venue for a berating necessites, IMO, a public venue
for an apology ... whether it will be forth coming, or not, is up to you.
Beth, I'm sorry to have instigated you to put on your political hat
so many times in these past two weeks (and folks, this has only been since
00/11/07). I know you're a big girl and can handle it, but if I had
NOT been so outspoken, maybe this would not have happened... Please
forgive me for egging you on. I never would have done it if I had
thought there were so many who would take offense...I know there are others,
but certainly I was one of the more frequent posters.
I start to understand why only 49% of the population votes... The other
51% preferring to come out of the woodwork only when it is time to whine...
Andrew Lietzow, Plantsman http://hostahaven.com
1250 41st Street 515-274-0300 voice
Des Moines, IA 50311-2516