Re: Judges' training, etc.
- To: Multiple recipients of list <email@example.com>
- Subject: Re: Judges' training, etc.
- From: Ensata@aol.com
- Date: Sun, 19 Oct 1997 07:30:17 -0600 (MDT)
In a message dated 97-10-17 12:58:36 EDT, Maureen wrote:
<< I have seen exhibits disqualified as the judge determined it was not the
right cultivar. This would be easy to do. When none of the judges are
familiar with the cultivar, they may refer to the check lists. The
check lists may not say that pattern variations occur regularly. This
is why it is important for judges to be familiar with the growing
patterns of as many cultivars as possible - either through growing them
or regular visits to other gardens.
The point that I was trying to make at Judges Training, was for judges to be
aware of the instability of color pattern in the splashed varieties ....
some, if not all, can throw a nearly solid color bloom....either near pure
white or more commonly, near pure violet. This is NOT okay. Deduct
points for color and pattern variance. I just want judges to be aware of
this and not too quickly mark the entry tag WRONG NAME. It is harsh to the
beginner exhibitor to have an entry in the iris show thrown out due to wrong
name. It is gentler to say "wrong color" or "not characteristic color".
"Wrong color" will bring out questions which can be answered or
explained......"wrong name" will bring out hostility which has to be tamed.
Oh, these cultivars are not registered with notes of possible color
variance! Because we all know, the bad things that plants or blossoms
do.......they wait and do it AFTER they have been registered and introduced
Ian noted: >At Burlington, we saw JI photos of what I can only call
irises". No formal structure, no symmetry, just a mass of petals and
deformed standards, etc. What are the rules to judge such a mess?<<
If you like the "mess", buy it. If you don't like the mess...don't buy it !
That is how the non-judge can vote for an iris. If one thinks an iris is
a mess, and lacks grace and balance, don't vote for it as a judge. A
judge's vote means that he/she is recommending that iris (bloom and plant
habits) to the public as one of the best of the newer introductions.
John Coble at Ensata.