Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked'
- Subject: Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked'
- From: D* &* L*
- Date: Sat, 26 Jan 2002 16:35:43 -0500
|
This came in today at 3:00PM from Chick and bounced
for reasons unknown to me.
Dan
=================
Chick wrote:
As far as I know, we have been given no guidance on naming streaked
forms
of already named plants. My understanding is that everything should be named, and unless two plants can be shown to be identical, they should have different names. <p>I think that for all practical purposes, most of us would agree that all streaked forms of Delta Dawn are the same plant, but since streaked plants are unstable, I'm not sure how we could say that any two are identical. So I guess that if two people find a streaked form of Delta Dawn, they would have to give them different names. <p>My personal opinion is that streaked plants should not be named, but that is definitely not AHS policy. I would rather name the stable plant and refer to all of the streaked forms as "the streaked form of 'Whatever'". Plants like 'Sea Prize' and other streaked breeders that have some standing should probably get a name of their own, but I can't see naming every streaked plant that pops up and pretending it's different from the one that someone else found. <p>It seems that I remember that Delta Dawn came from a steaked plant that took a very long time to stabilize into a margined form. I don't know that the original streaked form was ever named and distributed. Now we have plants that are reverting back to a streaked form and we're giving all of them new names. I'll have to ponder on this a while, but at first glance, it doesn't make sense to me. <p>Chick |
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked' or Delta Force
- From: "t*"
- From: "t*"
- Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked' or Delta Force
- Prev by Date: Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked'
- Next by Date: Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked' or Delta Force
- Previous by thread: Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked'
- Next by thread: Re: 'Delta Dawn-streaked' or Delta Force