Re: Re: Re: SPECIES: why here? germanica

Neil,

>Your
> suggestion of cross-posting (which I'm doing here ) 
offers an out.  But to
> keep Iris-photos on track as "iris photos" these kinds 
of discussions need to
> be shifted entirely over to Iris-talk, not just cross 
posted.

The problem is that some contributors to the discussion 
are not members of iris-talk.  They are members of iris-
photos.  I was surprised they could even cross post unless 
they were members.  I thought iris-photos would reject 
emails from non-member addresses.  At least Bob Pries has 
explained why he is not a member of iris-talk and unless 
he has changed his mind and subscribed, then I don't think 
he can post directly and solely to iris-talk on any 
thread.  

So the result would be the thread would not have input 
from non-members (unless non-members can indeed cross post 
as members of the other list).  The thread as it ran on 
iris-photos would likely have been substantially different 
without some of the postings that comprised the thread.  
If such a thread were soley initiated on iris-talk, those 
non-members would never be aware of it and would not be 
participants.

Donald Eaves
donald@eastland.net
Texas Zone 7b, USA


---------------------------------------------
This message was provided by TXOL Internet.
http://www.txol.net/

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To sign-off this list, send email to majordomo@hort.net with the
message text UNSUBSCRIBE IRIS
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index