This is a public-interest archive. Personal data is pseudonymized and retained under GDPR Article 89.

Re: Fertilizer


Stewart:

Fortunately, plants are pretty good at sorting out their nutrient supply needs, so long as we supply adequate amounts. The ratio of needs does chnage during the growing season, but unless you are in a very sandy soil, we can usually provide most (or all) of the annual needs as a soil application and let the plant take what it needs when it needs it.

Foliar application may be helpful as a supplement, but I have never been very excited about trying to feed all of the nutrients that way. Leaves are designed for CO2 and H20 exchange; roots are better equipped for meeting mineral nutrient requirements. I have been surprised at how effective the pumpkin roots are at taking up water and nutrients for a fairly large plant. Research has shown pumpkins need relatively high amounts of K and N. As you note, P requirement is higher around pollination time. This is similar in most plants---when they shift to the reproductive stage, there is a high P requirement. P is required as the backbone of the genetic code (DNA), and all energy conversion processes in the plant, so any time there is a lot of celll growth, there is a high P requirement. K is essential for all cell membrane transfers---such as water and nutrient uptake, opening and closing of stomates, etc. When K is deficient, the stomates become less effective in controlling H2O loss from the leaves, and CO2 assimilation. The roots become less able to take up water and nutriuents. K is also critical in maintaining diesease resistance. N is a major component of genetic material (DNA) and proteins and amino acids.....so again, whenever there is rapid growth or reproduction (seed and fruit development), there is a high N requirement.

The "salt" effect is a chemical reaction of certain materials. When an acid and a base react, a salt is formed. If that concentration is too high, it can burn the leaf tissue. High salt content can also burn roots, but if the nutrients are applied to the soil, the salt splits apart into component ions and is buffered by the soil, setting up an equilibrium situation so that nutrients are slowly released as the plant takes them out of soil solution.

 

Bottom line.....I would follow a good soil application program for fertilizer, supplementing with foliar during critical times if you like, but don' t depend on leaf absorption to meet the plant's needs. The products like Miracle Grow have low-salt forms of nutrients, and you will usually pay more per pound of actual nutrients, but you also get some safety factors that you may be willing to pay extra for. It is a good high quality nutrient source and the added cost will be negligible unless you get into large acreages. The convenience and local access may well be worth the added cost.

 

I am probably rambling on more than you want to know on this. Not knowing your biology and chemistry background, I don't know how much to go into this. You don't have to know all of the details to grow a good crop, just be sure there is an adequate supply of nutrients and let the plant sort out its needs. Then the limiting factor is likely to be water-----which is probably easier for most of us to supply and monitor.

 

Good luck for a BIG ONE!!!

 

----
From: Stewart Deans <sdeans@pcug.org.au>
To: Harold Reetz <hreetz@ppi-far.com>; pumpkins@athenet.net
Date: Wednesday, April 30, 1997 4:10 AM
Subject: Re: Fertilizer

Thanks Harold,
I am particularly interrested in foliant fertilizer and I guess by low salt
you mean low sodium or potassium.
I notice advice to increase the levels of P before pollination so I was
thinking of making a mix myself but as you indicate for the domestic
application the cost is not important and I could start with say a 10 10 10
mix and increase say the P component by suitable additive.
I guess the question is what are the low salt additives, alsodid you have
any advice on when to change the mixtures or is this less science than folk
lore.

Stewart


----------
From: Harold Reetz <h*@ppi-far.com>
To: p*@athenet.net; Stewart Deans <s*@pcug.org.au>
Subject: Re: Fertilizer
Date: Wednesday, 30 April 1997 4:37

There are several different sources of N, P, and K used to make fertrilizer
formulations.  Generally for dry fertilizer materials, the P comes from
diammonium phosphate (DAP), and the K comes from potassium chloride (KCl).
The N is supplied from the DAP as well.  Since DAP is 18-46-0 and KCl is
0-0-60 or 0-0-62, they are blended to make the formulation you want.  The
additional N may come from Urea (45-0-0) added to the mix, or ammonium
sulfate or some other N source.    For liquid fertilizers, other sources of
N, P or K may be used, depending on the solubility and on the desired use.
Urea-ammonium nitrate solution is often used as the N source and potassium
hydroxide (KOH) for the K source.  Phosphoric acid is the raw ingredient
for the P source.  It comes in different concentrations. 
For foliar applications, the materials used as N, P, K sources need to have
a low salt level to avoid injury to the leaves.  This usually means a
higher cost raw material.  But for small amounts used in gardens, this is
not a serious cost difference.  The garden and lawn fertilizers generally
have a lower analysis than fertilizers used for farm fields, so it takes
more material to get the same amount of nutrients.  This makes it easier to
get a uniform rate of application and reduces potential injury to the
plants.  These low analysis products are less practical for field
application because of the volume needed to provide adequate nutrients to
the crops.  Handling and transportation would be very expensive relative to
the more concentrated fertilizer materials.
If you would like more detail on this, feel free to send me an e-mail.
Harold Reetz

----
From: Stewart Deans <s*@pcug.org.au>
To: p*@athenet.net
Date: Tuesday, April 29, 1997 7:28 AM
Subject: Fertilizer

Hi,
When mixing fertilizer for 10 30 10 or 10 10 10 what solutions are used is
it
Sulphate of ammonia
superposphate
sulphate of potash
or are there others?

What is the difference between a general liquid fertilizer and a foliant?
and what are the recommended percentages at various growing times?

Stewart; ACT


Follow-Ups:
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index