This is a public-interest archive. Personal data is pseudonymized and retained under GDPR Article 89.

Re: Rosa eglanteria/rose gall -Reply

Out of 70+ roses I've never had this before
UNTIL I had this rose.  I don't believe it's
crown gall, nothing going on there.  I realize
they may look for another host, but my book
said they typically went for species roses, and
this is the only one I have.

I have removed the canes, its more of a matter
of being able to check for this in the future and
the fact that its happened twice in about 1
month that concerns me.  The rose grows on a
shared fence with a neighbor and I won't have
access to "1/2" the rose, and they aren't
interested in watching the rose on their side.  I
don't see that I will be able to really keep an
eye on the rose and don't want it getting out of
hand because of that or spreading.

I appreciate your opinion and advice/experience.

First, I would make sure you have "rose gall,"
and not "crown gall," which
is a serious bacterial disease. Second, since you
have established a
pattern, it appears like removing that particular
plant *may* provide
relief. In my experience, however, the wasps
that are responsible will
merely select another victim if their preferred
host in unavailable. How bad
is this problem? removing a cane or two should
be all that is required to
eliminate the problem.

-Dave-


-----Original Message-----
From: SUSAN SAXTON <SS@Schwabe.com>
To: rose-list@eskimo.com
<rose-list@eskimo.com>
Date: Tuesday, August 04, 1998 1:29 AM
Subject: Rosa eglanteria/rose gall


>Second year in my garden for this rose.  And
>second time this year I found that tennis ball
>shaped, moss covered stuff that according to
>one of my rose books is rose gall (where the
>insect bores into the cane, lays eggs and as
eggs
>grow, cane swells).  For some reason, this
>absolutely grosses me out!
>
>Anyway.  My book says its common to
species
>roses.  This is the only rose I have that gets
>this.  Is this going to be a common problem?
>I'd rather get rid of the rose than deal with
this.
> I have about 70+ roses on a 70 x 100 city lot,
>all old, English, a few teas.
>
>Anyone have experience with this? Any help
is
>appreciated!
>
>
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index