Re: Replies to list

I strongly agree with John's sentiments -- I find many of our discussions apparently prematurely terminated, probably because of the "reply to sender" setting of the listserver.

I am also a list owner on a couple of lists, and I found that we had to change to "reply to list" to keep any discussions alive. Now, of course, more than once I've sent a reply intended to be private to the whole list -- which serves to help keep me humble (maybe). It also reminds me not to say anything in a private e-mail that I would not want forwarded to (potentially) several hundred million of my fellow human beings.

I'm definitely enjoying the current discussions, and I thank everyone who is responding to the whole list.

Jim Shields
in central Indiana, where the temperature is finally above freezing outdoors

At 12:50 PM 1/28/03 -0800, John MacGregor wrote:
on 1/27/03 8:08 PM, emhoffs at emhoffs@ucla.edu wrote:

> Dear Respondents - I have received five very interesting and helpful
> responses to my query about planting Leucadendrons - each one different
> from the other.  However, the responses have been posted to my email rather
> than medit-plants@ucdavis.edu.  I think everyone would be interested in
> reading these responses and hope that you will send them to the
> Mediterranean site.   Thank you.
>
> Ellen Hoffs
> Santa Monica, CA

Ellen,

I love this list and I think that Sean does a great job of monitoring it,
but my one peeve is that answers go to the individual rather than the list,
unless the respondent remembers to hit "reply all" or paste in the list
address (which I usually don't, and I suspect others don't either).  I
believe this truncates many interesting discussion threads which would be of
wider interest.    As an owner of several other lists, I know that you get a
few extraneous messages which SHOULD have gone to individuals if replies to
go the the list, but I consider this a small price to pay for wider response
and continuity.  I wonder if Sean might consider changing the setting for
Medit-Plants to "replies to list"--at least as an experiment?

John MacGregor
South Pasadena, CA 91030
USDA zone 9   Sunset zones 21/23

*************************************************
Jim Shields             USDA Zone 5             Shields Gardens, Ltd.
P.O. Box 92              WWW:    http://www.shieldsgardens.com/
Westfield, Indiana 46074, USA                   Tel. +1-317-896-3925
Member of INTERNATIONAL CLIVIA CO-OP
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index