Re: INDIANA STATE RECORD

Brad please think.. ...you have put alot of work into your organization and I commend you.... but you just answered your own question regarding Tom's pumpkin....( do you think it should count if its oozing fluid at a stead rate while still on the scales)....come on Brad you didn't draw that conclusion then, you were right there apparently from the e-mail you sent the list...... ??? Tom's not part of this....someone else decided and he excepted it .....it stands and live with it....read rule 7 and 8 GPC....especially rule 8.....the judges reserve the right to fully inspect each specimen before the weight is annouced and official. Refusal to allow the inspection of an entry will cause said entry to be deemed EXHIBITION ONLY....Brad you and any other IPGA  board member there should have known this...could have pointed it out..especially if this site was an IPGA affiliate..look last year in Ottawa a pumpkin was brought to the weigh-off that was borderline pumpkin or squash.the grower asked for it to be classified if I remember correctly....the judges ruled it pumpkin...I am sure some growers thought different....decision was final....should they now take back the call.... let me see the 1260 Weir was judged a pumpkin....hmmm....heard all kinds of opinions on that decision...I saw a picture ( all pumpkin to me)...if others thought it was a squash tough, the judges decided....all I see by the IPGA decision is to take away from Tom's moment....sad day...wayne
----- Original Message -----
From: B*@aol.com
To: p*@hort.net
Sent: Wednesday, September 25, 2002 2:57 PM
Subject: Re: INDIANA STATE RECORD

Andrew and others,
                             The weigh-off at Hubers is an IPGA affiliated weigh-off.  As is the Indiana State Fair and the Noblesville weigh-off.  Maybe you need to read a little closer.  We accepted the judges decision that day and agreed that Tom was the winner.  
      Andrew, if you bring a 1263 to the weigh-off this year and set the new world record, do you think it should count if it is oozing fluid at a steady rate while it is still on the scale?  If you can answer that yes with a clear conscience let me know.
      For the record, the judges and the host did approach me, the site coordinator, and ask me what they should do.  I told them this is situation we have never seen before.  I also ask them.  Did it pass the final inspection you gave it?  They said "yes"   By the rules the judges had every right to make the decision the did.  I agreed with them in their decision.  However, the question still remains.  Was this pumpkin, that was still sitting on the scale free of damage and rot?  No

Would you like to trade places with me?

Brad

Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index