Re: Growing arums in pots
- Subject: Re: Growing arums in pots
- From: P* B* <p*@googlemail.com>
- Date: Wed, 8 Feb 2012 07:55:55 +0800
Hi Christopher, Sorry, I thought you were referring to acceptance of names post-publication (for which in Fungi there IS a committee). In order to publish in botany there are the same set of “hurdles” as there are for zoology. Very best Peter From: aroid-l-bounces@www.gizmoworks.com [mailto:aroid-l-bounces@www.gizmoworks.com] On Behalf Of D. Christopher Rogers Thanks for the great review of the species in Arum. One issue though, Peter: you said that there is no refereeing, just general acceptance. I have no real clue how things are done in the botanical realm, but in the zoological realm all species descriptions that are submitted to quality scientific white literature (as opposed to grey) type journals are in fact refereed. Typically, two to four referees give the manuscripts a solid review before they are accepted (or rejected) for publication. There are certain standards of taxonomy in zoology. Happy days, Christopher On Wed, Feb 1, 2012 at 1:30 AM, Peter Boyce <p*@googlemail.com> wrote: Hi David, Yes, there have been a few changes since 1993 and even since 2006. sintensii was ‘raised’ to spevcies in the 2006 paper; cylindraceum (which I treated as a nom. dub. in 1993) has been shown to be the same as A. alpinum and, as it was published earlier, now must be used. Arum lucanum is a syn. of A. cylindraceum (tackled in 2006) Regarding descriptions, sorry, but for most of those not in the book you have to go back to the original publication place. Of course this raises new problems in that most are not described in English. The full ‘official’ list for Arum is: 1. Arum alpinariae (K.Alpinar & R.R.Mill) P.C.Boyce 2. Arum amoenum (Engl.) Dubovik 3. Arum apulum (Carano) P.C.Boyce 4. Arum balansanum R.R.Mill. 5. Arum besserianum Schott 6. Arum byzantinum Blume 7. Arum concinnatum Schott 8. Arum creticum Boiss. & Heldr. 9. Arum cylindraceum Gasp. 10. Arum cyrenaicum Hruby 11. Arum dioscoridis Sm. 12. Arum elongatum Steven 13. Arum euxinum R.R.Mill 14. Arum gallowayi sp. nov. ined. 15. Arum gratum Schott 16. Arum hainesii Agnew & Hadac ex H. Riedl 17. Arum hygrophilum Boiss. 18. Arum idaeum Coust. & Gandoger 19. Arum italicum Miller ssp. albispathum (Steven ex Ledeb.) Prime ssp. canariensis (Webb. & Berth.) P.C.Boyce 20. Arum jacquemontii Blume 21. Arum korolkowii Regel 22. Arum longispathum Reich. 23. Arum maculatum L. 24. Arum maurum (Braun-Blanq. & Maire) stat. nov. ined. 25. Arum megobrebi Lobin, M.Neumann, Bogner & P.C.Boyce 26. Arum melanopus Schott 27. Arum nigrum Schott 28. Arum orientale Bieb. 29. Arum palaestinum Boiss. Arum pictum L.f. = Gymnomesium pictum (L.f.) Schott 30. Arum purpureospathum P.C.Boyce 31. Arum rupicola Boiss. 32. Arum sintenisii (Engl.) P.C.Boyce In addition to the above, I am aware of five further novel species (but of which I have seen only images) that are in cultivation in the USA, the Netherlands & Poland. I am also now convinced that my treatment of the species A. rupicola and A. orientale were both too broad: at least A. conophalloides, Arum consobrinum Schott, and A. incomptum probably need to be resurrected. Regarding ‘refereeing’ – no-one does this; it is all down to general acceptance. Peter From: aroid-l-bounces@www.gizmoworks.com [mailto:aroid-l-bounces@www.gizmoworks.com] On Behalf Of DAVID LEEDY
D. Christopher Rogers Crustacean Taxonomist and Ecologist
Vice President, Southwest Association of Freshwater Invertebrate Taxonomists SAFIT.ORG |
_______________________________________________ Aroid-L mailing list Aroid-L@www.gizmoworks.com http://www.gizmoworks.com/mailman/listinfo/aroid-l
- Prev by Date: Re: Publication offer for "Studies on Monstereae (Araceae) of Peninsular Malaysia I: Rhaphidophora megasperma, a New Record for West Malaysia"
- Next by Date: Re: About Those Holes
- Previous by thread: Re: Publication offer for "Studies on Monstereae (Araceae) of Peninsular Malaysia I: Rhaphidophora megasperma, a New Record for West Malaysia"
- Next by thread: March IAS Newsletter is (e) mailed