Re: Re: award system

 

Another factor, particularly for spuria iris, is that  in most years, for Canadians,  they haven't bloomed by time it comes for ballet to be sent in.

I've sent comments to Judges chair several times about this, but, they  didn't see it as a concern
  Several differerent chairs. Also mentioned it to Spuria iris society. Again, not much concern. Well actually some, but buraucracy seen as too big a burden to deal with. And likely not enough people in Canada into spuria to make miuch difference.

As an aside, I've been promoting them in Canada for some time and interest is increasing geatly. Particularly now that prairie people are finding out that they do very well for them.

Chuck Chapman
 

-----Original Message-----
From: Christy Hensler <hensler@povn.com>
To: iris-species@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Sat, Nov 27, 2010 10:29 pm
Subject: [iris-species] Re: award system

 
Just a casual observance here...
 
The awards system may inadvertently favor bearded cvs simply because of time limitations.
 
Bearded irises have an advantage simply because most people are familiar with the growing conditions needed for them.  I doubt that most people realize how long it may take some species and species-x irises to settle into a new garden and perform at peak. It's quite often a matter of the grower getting lucky enough to finally stumble upon the ideal microclimate after a number of attempts and this can take years.
 
A case in point: 'Alley Oops' did well enough here in the garden at large, managing to produce a few nice blooms each season with slow but steady increase. When moved to a pot and given a permanent place in the fish pond, has turned into a show stopper with the most aggressive increase I've seen short of pseudacorus.
 
The other reason, and it's a huge one, Tall Bearded irises may have the biggest advantage is that most commercial growers find that the general public hasn't a clue that other irises even exist. It takes a lot of effort to grow species and species-x irises as well as a financial incentive. When bearded irises sell better, it only makes sense that most gardens will favor them over other types.
 
I like the idea of a tierred method of judging. Those people familiar with a species or type could single out cvs of merit who then would hand off the judging to another group familiar with even more types until an educated consensus is reached.
 
Christy Hensler
Newport, WA
16" of new snow today and still coming down...
 
 
 

Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index