This is a public-interest archive. Personal data is pseudonymized and retained under GDPR Article 89.

FW: suppressing native grasses

Good points, Cliff.

I shouldn't, but somehow I keep forgetting (re: #2, below) that my own
experience here, with slightly acidic and somewhat nitrogen-limited soils
may not transfer to other other sites, especially restorations on more
recently farmed ground.

As for which species have colonized from sowing already grassy sites with
the help of fall or winter burning and mechanical suppression of grasses,
some I've seen succeed include: Pedicularis canadensis, Dodecatheon meadia,
Baptisia alba (=leucantha), Penstemon digitalis, Eryngium yuccifolium,
Silphium laciniatum, Physostegia speciosa (upland species often mislabeled
by the name of the moist-soil species P. virginiana).

-----Original Message-----
From: welsch@pilot.msu.edu
To: prairie@hort.net
Sent: 4/2/2003 11:24 AM
Subject: suppressing native grasses

     How many of us over the years in the midwest, at some point, have
planted native warm-season grasses (C4) too thick.  I for one certainly
have, especially in the beginning of my native grassland restoration
efforts in south-central Michigan.  After examining 100's of tallgrass
prairie restoration/reconstruction projects in the midwest, it is clear
that the answer to the above question is "many, if not most individuals
have."
    I am now spending time in developing strategies in which to "thin"
such
stands of native grasses.  Some thoughts on this subject follows.
1.  The ability to appropriately "thin" such grasses is not as easy as
it
might seem.  I have experimented with the glyphosate family of
herbicides,
almost exclusively Roundup Ultra.  The ability of this herbicide to
"thin"
these grasses is a function of herbicide dose, climatic conditions at
time
of herbicide application, type of grass species (e.g. which species,
which
cultivar, etc.), grass age (extent of the root system), etc.  Let me
give
you a couple of examples from such activities of mine in Michigan.  I
have
completely "wiped-out" Indian Grass in a one-acre plot of mixed C4
native
grasses (5 species), effectively "thining" 2 grass species (Big
Bluestem,
Little Bluestem) in this plot, while not,in this plot, affecting 2 grass
species (Switchgrass and Side-oats Grama).  I used a relatively low dose
of
the above herbicide (1 qt/acre), administered once in mid-June.  In
another
one-acre plot of only Switchgrass, to effectively fully kill this grass,
it
required 3 consecutive high doses of this herbicide (3
qts/acre)(administered once in June, July and August). [Parenthetically,
I
have spent considerable time in killing very thick monocultures of
Switchgrass (usually Cave-in Rock cultivar) plots, a function of
mis-informed Pheasants Forever activities in our state.]  I should point
out that all of these grass "thining" projects involve plots with only
planted native grasses, no native forbs. So, be careful, start with a
very
low dose of glyphosate (1% or less) and work your way up in
concentration.
2. I am intrigued with James Trager's suggestion (Shaw Nature Preserve,
Missouri), i.e., late fall burning of native grass stands followed by
hand
scattering of native forb seeds (then mowing the following 1 or 2
years).
Most native forb seeds germinate best when scattered in fall, especially
after a burn. I would like to know, in his studies, which native forbs
can
best compete with the thick stands of native grasses.
3. Lightly disking or tilling soil prior to scattering of native forb
seeds
in native grass stands can have a very substantial negative effect, so
be
cautious!  I have disturbed the soil in this manner, the result was an
"explosion" of seedlings of un-wanted aggressive and persistent
non-natives, e.g., Yellow and White Sweet Clovers, Queen Ann's Lace,
Bull
Thistle, etc.  I do not disturb the soil in any native grass plot if
historically that site has had a substantial amount of these non-native
plants.  Indeed, I will not plant native forbs in native grass sites
until
I have eliminated, via broad-leaf herbicides, the presence of the above
named non-natives.
  Thick stands of native grasses can be a substantial problem when the
objective is (or at least should be) to have a native prairie with a
balance of grasses and forbs.   Especially, as in my state of Michigan,
where we are just now getting sufficient quantities of native grass
seeds,
with Michigan genotype, for our restoration activities. Thus, in the
past,
our only source of native grass seeds have been native grass cultivars.
These cultivars are often very aggressive and have varying sensitivities
to
herbicides (often more resistant then native genotypes). So again, I
view
our current problem of excessively thick native grasses a relevant
problem,
one that needs to be addressed, a problem that one must approach, when
using herbicides, with substantial caution.
Cliff Welsch

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To sign-off this list, send email to majordomo@hort.net with the
message text UNSUBSCRIBE PRAIRIE

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To sign-off this list, send email to majordomo@hort.net with the
message text UNSUBSCRIBE PRAIRIE
Other Mailing lists | Author Index | Date Index | Subject Index | Thread Index