Re: Defending Pinellia ternata again ???
Dear Aroid-L, Tony, Diana etc;
After hearing your horror stories I really got to thinking about it
and in all fairness to P. ternata; it is, in my garden, less aggressive and
weedy than either P. tripartita OR P. pedatisecta. Both the latter self sow
fairly actively, whereas I get little bloom and few seeds out of P.
ternata. Certainly its various stem bulbils do a job in moving around, but
they can't match the rate of movement of the other two.
I think it is my harsh climate (Zone 5/6) , winter lows of -15 to
-20 degrees F and low annual rainfall (about 40 inches VERY unevenly) that
keep these all in check.
I know that in my cold "greenhouse" both pedatisecta and tripartita
get very lush and seed around the dirt/gravel floor and every other pot.
This is kept around freezing in winter, but stays warm in fall and warms up
in spring enough to moderate. I don't think I have ternata in this
'greenhouse' for comparison so I can't tell.
On the other hand if I lived ina really moderate climate, I'd
probably just plant something else although I do like all three of these a
best Jim W.
James W. Waddick Voice: 816 746 1949
8871 NW Brostrom Rd E-MAIL: email@example.com
Kansas City MO 64152 Fax: 816 746 1939
Zone 5/6 -
Winter low -10=B0F
Summer high +100=B0F
Other Mailing lists |
Author Index |
Date Index |
Subject Index |